Get the PDFInstant download — play tonight Grab the PaperbackShips from Amazon
    Instagram YouTube
    • Newsletter
    • Resources
    • Ideas That Didn’t Make It
    • NPCs
    • Shop
    • Items
    Instagram YouTube RSS
    Dumbest DnDDumbest DnD
    • All Encounters

      Get Lucky with Lute Boxes

      June 3, 2024

      Calvin and the Drip Monks

      April 16, 2024

      Total Eclipse of the Art

      April 7, 2024

      Take Me Out To The Skull Game

      April 3, 2024

      Are You in Good Hands?

      February 14, 2024
    • By Location
      • Any Location
      • Arctic
      • Cave
      • Coastal
      • Desert
      • Dungeon
      • Farm
      • Forest
      • Grassland / Plain
      • Graveyard
      • Island
      • Lake
      • Mountain
      • Ocean
      • Swamp
      • Urban (City/Town)
    • By Level
      • Any Level
      • 1-3
      • 4-7
      • 8-11
      • 12+
    • By Type
      • Defend
      • Destroy
      • Escort
      • Fetch
      • Minigame
      • Mystery
      • Roleplay
      • Stealth
    • Archive
    • Shop
    Dumbest DnDDumbest DnD
    Get 200+ drop-in D&D encounters for under TEN CENTS EACH →
    Home»Resources»Spells»Level 1»Hail of Thorns Spell in D&D: Uses, Cheeses, and Shooting Your Own Barbarian
    Level 1

    Hail of Thorns Spell in D&D: Uses, Cheeses, and Shooting Your Own Barbarian

    dumbestdndBy dumbestdndNo Comments16 Mins Read
    Share Facebook Twitter Pinterest LinkedIn Tumblr Reddit Email
    Share
    Facebook Twitter LinkedIn Pinterest Email

    The companion piece. If you want the rules, the save math, and the whole 2014 versus 2024 breakdown, that’s all in the Hail of Thorns explainer post. Go read that first, then come back, because this one is about what the spell can do once you stop treating it as the thing you skipped for Hunter’s Mark.

    Hail of Thorns spent ten years as the ranger spell everybody read once and never prepared. Then 2024 dropped its concentration and the conversation restarted. So I went through the Reddit threads, the rules arguments, the math posts, and the cursed corners, and sorted it into four buckets. Real uses that lean on the rules. Cheeses that are clever and legal. Questionable stuff that lives or dies at your table. And the deviant pile, because somebody always finds a way.

    Fair warning up front. This spell has a thinner Reddit footprint than most, because for a decade the community answer was one sentence long. The threads that do exist are good, and I’m citing every one as I go so you can check me. Fight me in the comments, but bring the permalink.

    REAL USES

    1. Two adjacent enemies is the break-even, three is where it sings. The whole spell is priced around the cluster. One target alone means you spent a first level slot on a single save-for-half d10, which is a bad afternoon. The r/3d6 crowd landed on this immediately, “Hail of Thorns is worth the slot if there’s a few enemies side by side. Best paired with a Push Mastery weapon like Heavy Crossbows. If there’s just one enemy it feels a waste of a spell slot,” and another poster put the enthusiasm level plainly, “It’s a pretty solid spell to use IF the enemies are grouped up. I wouldn’t use it against a single enemy. I would be SUPER excited in a situation where it would hit 3.” (u/milenyo and u/That-Wolverine1526, r/3d6)

    2. In 2024 it rides along with Hunter’s Mark instead of replacing it. The 2024 version has no concentration, so your mark stays up while the thorns go off. The compiled ranger spell changes thread put it plainly, “Hail of Thorns: no concentration. Activates on-hit with a Bonus Action like the new Smite spells,” and Treantmonk showed up in the same thread to confirm which sibling kept theirs, “I promise that Ensnaring Strike still requires concentration.” The r/3d6 post that kicked off the 2024 reappraisal said the same thing from the other end, the spell “doesn’t use concentration so doesn’t clash with other good spells like conjure woodland beings or conjure animals.” (u/Envoyofwater and u/Treantmonk, r/onednd ; u/jmrkiwi, r/3d6, r/3d6)

    3. Nobody in the blast escapes clean, so a mediocre spell save DC hurts less than usual. Half damage on a success means a bad Wisdom score costs you the difference between 5.5 and 2.75 rather than the whole slot. Ensnaring Strike runs the other way, where one good Strength save eats your entire turn. As the r/3d6 post framed it, the spell “damages creatures next to the original target and because it is save for half damage is not very sensitive to a lower wisdom than Dex.” (u/jmrkiwi, r/3d6)

    4. It’s the only smite-style spell you can throw from eighty feet away. Every paladin smite is melee. This one wants a bow, which means you’re contributing burst damage without standing in the blender. “It works with ranged attacks which is great from a survivability point of view.” (u/jmrkiwi, r/3d6)

    5. Your arrow still does everything it was going to do. The spell says “in addition to the normal effect of the attack,” so weapon die, Dexterity, Archery style, Colossus Slayer, Hunter’s Mark, and a 2024 weapon mastery all land as normal and then the thorns go off on top. One correction to a common Reddit claim, though. People say Hunter’s Mark adds 1d6 to Hail of Thorns. It adds 1d6 to the arrow, because the mark triggers on hitting with an attack roll and the thorn damage comes off a saving throw. (Claim as stated by u/Business-Size2975, r/DnD ; correction from the Player’s Handbook text, 2014 page 249 and 2024 page 283)

    6. Horde Breaker is the Hunter subclass feature that guarantees the condition. Horde Breaker lets you make a second attack “against a different creature that is within 5 feet of the original target.” If Horde Breaker is even available to you this turn, a second enemy is already standing inside the thorn radius. The two features are written around the same five feet. The r/3d6 poster spotted it, “Hail of thorns plus hoard breakers is a pretty decent combo!” (u/jmrkiwi, r/3d6 ; Horde Breaker text, Player’s Handbook 2014 and 2024 Hunter subclass)

    7. Thorn damage punches through “nonmagical attacks” resistance. The 1d10 comes from a spell, so the extremely common monster resistance to bludgeoning, piercing, and slashing from nonmagical attacks does nothing against it, even while your arrows are getting shrugged off. A monster with flat piercing resistance still halves it. (Rules as written, not a thread.)

    8. Know why you’d take Lightning Arrow instead, so you can stop taking Lightning Arrow instead. A ranger asked r/dndnext why Lightning Arrow exists when a 3rd level Hail of Thorns does more, and the honest answers are the two things Lightning Arrow has. “The big difference is that you can use Lightning Arrow after hitting or missing with your attack. So you’re guaranteed damage. Plus a bigger AOE.” A separate breakdown added the third, that Lightning Arrow’s single target damage skips the save entirely, “which means it bypasses Evasion-like-abilities and is still effective vs creatures that are good at Dex saves.” On raw numbers the smaller spell wins. One poster ran it clean and concluded, “It is clear that for both single target and AoE damage, HoT is better. In fact, too much better than LA.” (u/Vanse and u/Umbraspem, r/dndnext ; u/OptimalTeach5585, r/DnD, r/DnD)

    CHEESES (clever, and completely legal)

    9. The one level Ranger dip that gives a caster a ranged nuke button. This is the sharpest 2024 idea in the whole pile. A cleric or druid takes a single level of Ranger, picks up armor, weapon masteries, and this spell, and now has a bonus action damage rider that fires off a crossbow bolt. “A cleric or druid for example can take a 1 level ranger dip for hail of thorns and use it in conjunction with true strike and a heavy crossbow to have a viable single target damage option which is something that these classes struggled with historically.” The same poster wrote up the wizard version, an evoker who dips one Ranger level, uses a shortbow with Vex and True Strike, and keeps near full spell progression. (u/jmrkiwi, r/3d6)

    10. Keep a dart in your pocket. In 2024 the trigger requires a Ranged weapon, and a dart is a Simple Ranged weapon with the Thrown and Finesse properties. So a melee character with this spell can pull a dart mid-Attack action and set off the thorns without carrying a bow. “A good trick with this is the dart. It’s a ranged weapon. It can easily be drawn and thrown to work it into a larger attack action where you have more going on.” (u/That-Wolverine1526, r/3d6 ; dart entry, 2024 Player’s Handbook weapon table)

    11. Swarmkeeper, shove them together and then detonate. A Swarmkeeper’s Gathered Swarm can move a target up to 15 feet on a failed Strength save, and it triggers immediately after you hit, which is exactly when Hail of Thorns triggers. So you shove the archer 15 feet sideways into his friend and set off the thorns on both. A poster asked whether the ordering works and the original poster confirmed the reading, “Would this work with swarmkeeper’s forced movement to push the target closer to other enemies and then activate the spell? Both gathered swarm and hail of thorns are activated immediately after a ranged weapon attack,” answered with “yes these stack.” In 2024 the Simultaneous Effects rule lets you pick the order. In 2014 it’s a friendly DM call. (u/SoulContact and u/jmrkiwi, r/3d6)

    12. It’s the damage button for any ranger whose subclass is chained to Hunter’s Mark. A concentration-free damage rider is worth the most to a character whose concentration is already spoken for permanently. One r/3d6 poster called the shape of it, “The subclasses where this spell stands out are ones that must concentrate on hunter’s mark in order to have a subclass,” and named Winter Walker and Hollow Warden from Unearthed Arcana as the examples, with the honest caveat that neither was published yet. Any future subclass built that way is this spell’s best home. And on the slot budget, a reply pointed out the 2024 ranger is richer than people assume, “Thanks to Favored Enemy, Rangers have more slots than paladins.” (u/SavageWolves and u/YOwololoO, r/3d6)

    13. Cast it low, almost always. Each slot level adds one d10, and each d10 gets split across a Dexterity save. Against two targets a 2nd level slot buys you about eight extra points of expected damage. Against one, four. As one poster put it, “It’s fine. Just be careful using it when in close range, and it’s just not a great use of upper level spell slots. At 5th level, is 2d10 worth one of your 2nd level slots?” Upcast this only when you can see three bodies inside the circle. (u/Ald_Bathhouse_John, r/3d6)

    QUESTIONABLE (check with your table)

    14. Does the Piercer feat apply to the thorns? No, and this one got argued in the thread itself. One poster said “it looks like the piercer feat also applies to this spell. It’s very niche and a bit silly but still funny,” and got corrected, “i dont think the piercer feat applies to the hail of thorns spell, just the arrow damage as the feat specifies damage from attack not piercing damage overall.” The correction is right. Piercer says you reroll one of “the attack’s damage dice,” and the thorn damage belongs to the spell, not the attack. Reroll your arrow, leave the d10 alone. The same wall blocks crits, Sneak Attack, and Colossus Slayer on the spell half, since a critical hit doubles the attack’s damage dice and the 1d10 rides on a saving throw instead. Another poster in the thread summarized that trade in one line, “Upside no waster slots, downside it’s not an on hit effect from the attack so it can’t critical.” (u/TheActualAWdeV, u/Pyrotech_Nick, and u/Sofa-king-high, r/3d6 ; Piercer feat text, Tasha’s page 80 and 2024 Player’s Handbook page 206)

    15. Thrown weapons: yes in 2014, no in 2024, and people are still fighting about it. In 2014 the trigger is a ranged weapon attack, and one r/DnD thread nailed the reading, “A ranged weapon attack does not necessarily mean an attack with a ranged weapon.” A commenter in that thread argued the opposite, then came back and corrected himself, “Throwing bar stools can totally trigger hail of thorns.” In 2024 the answer flips, because the casting time now says Ranged weapon, which is a category on the weapon table. Somebody asked about Shadow Blade specifically and got shut down three ways, “No. Shadow Blade explicitly conjures a melee weapon. The Thrown property doesn’t make a melee weapon ranged,” then “Ranged Weapons are those listed as such in the PHB – bows and crossbows etc. A dagger has a throw distance but is not a Ranged Weapon,” and then, best of all, “A ranged attack does not a ranged weapon make.” Javelins and handaxes are out in 2024. (u/VenomousFeudalist and u/GMatthew, r/DnD ; u/Yojo0o, u/AmethystWind, and u/yaniism, r/DnD, r/DnD)

    16. Do flying creatures overhead get caught in it? A DM brought this exact geometry problem to r/DMAcademy, target on the ground, flyers twenty feet up but lined up with it on the grid. The consensus was no, and the reasoning is worth stealing, “It doesn’t originate from the sky, it originates from your weapon / ammo. It only affects the target and creatures within 5 ft of it.” Another put it as a rule of thumb, “I just imagine that the grid is 3D even if we usually are only looking at the 2D portion of it.” One reply raised the fun edge case, “If the creature is 15 feet tall and the flyers are 20 feet off the ground I’d say they hit.” Shoot a giant, catch the harpies. DM call. (u/coolcrowe, u/olliequeengreenarrow, and u/Onrawi, r/DMAcademy)

    17. Hail of Thorns plus Conjure Barrage does not work, no matter how good it sounds. The dream is casting the thorns, then firing Conjure Barrage so every conjured arrow spreads them. It doesn’t, and the reason is clean, “Conjure Barrage is a spell and not an attack. There is no attack roll, it’s a spell save. So RAW, you cannot use HoT and CB together- they do not stack at all.” One reply added the backstop, “Even if Conjure Barrage was a ranged weapon attack, Hail of Thorns would still only trigger on the first hit.” (u/Cypher_Blue and u/Hironymos, r/DnD)

    18. Yes, your main target also rolls a save. A new player brought his DM’s ruling to r/DnD to check it and the ruling was correct. The arrow damage hits the target only, then the target and everyone within five feet roll Dexterity saves for the thorn damage. The line by line walkthrough in that thread ends “Everyone determined in the previous step takes the AOE damage.” So on a great turn your target eats the arrow plus a failed save, and on a normal turn it eats the arrow plus 2.75. (u/jward, r/DnD)

    19. How do you use a Hail of Thorns spell scroll in 2024? Genuine puzzle, since the casting time now happens in the split second after your arrow lands. As the poster asked, “You need to be able to read it upon the triggering hit mid-attack, so have the scroll taped to your arm while wielding a bow with two hands?” The two best answers were “Use a hand crossbow” and “play a thri-kreen.” Both work. (u/redbeard1991, u/RTukka, and u/subtotalatom, r/DnD)

    DEVIANT, FUNNY, AND CURSED

    20. Five encounters. One usable cast. The best data point on the friendly fire problem came from somebody actually playing it. “I played a ranger with HoT for 5 encounters and could use it once without hitting an ally.” He blamed his initiative roll and a melee heavy party. The spell needs your friends to be standing somewhere else, and your friends have their own plans. (u/Silentray, r/3d6)

    21. The monk who wasn’t there. The friendly fire question has its own r/DnD thread, and the answers range from resigned, “Yes. I’ve been hit by collateral damage before. Such is the life of a tank,” to the flat rule, “All AoE spells in D&D cause friendly fire, unless a spell description specifically says otherwise.” Then somebody delivered the perfect table story. The party split up, the ranger ran into a demon alone, cast Hail of Thorns, and “the monk replied, ‘Why are you casting that? I’m not there.'” (u/ironboy32, u/Throrface, and u/PaulSharke, r/DnD)

    22. The best Hail of Thorns post ever made is a cartoon. Somebody spent a week in Adobe Animate making a short animation of the spell, posted it to r/DungeonsAndDragons, and it cleared a thousand upvotes, which is more attention than the spell got in ten years of rules threads. The comments are people asking for the arrow to split in slow motion so they can see it. The animator’s own verdict on the spell, in the same thread, “It’s a good low level ranger spell, but useless in most dungeon settings.” (u/SeigeEh, r/DungeonsAndDragons)

    23. Baldur’s Gate 3 turned this spell into a physics exploit, and it’s not even the same spell. Two things first. The video game version explodes on a miss, which tabletop never does, and the whole trick runs on Twinned Spell, which cannot touch this spell at a real table. The 2014 metamagic requires a spell that “doesn’t have a range of self,” and Hail of Thorns has a range of self. The 2024 metamagic only works on spells that gain a target when you upcast them, and this one gains a d10. With that said, somebody decompiled the game to figure out why a twinned Hail of Thorns behaves like a completely different spell, and posted the decompiled logic. In the game, the plain version “can’t crit,” you “can’t trigger a Sneak attack off of it,” and “if the target fails the Saving throw, the Attack will always count as a hit (even if you crit fail!)”. Twin it and all of that reverses on the second target. The engine sets a Hit flag on a successful spell roll and then never unsets it. A separate build guide ran five whole characters off this behavior. (u/Jukervic, r/BG3Builds ; u/truthatenvy, r/BG3Builds, r/BG3Builds)

    24. The ten year complaint, preserved in amber. Before 2024, this spell was exhibit A in every “the ranger doesn’t work” post on the internet. The most upvoted one walks through it step by step, a level 11 ranger who wants to do something cool “so you have to drop Hunter’s Mark, throw up Hail of Thorns, and then next turn cast Hunter’s Mark again,” and lands on the tally, “The Ranger had to spend 3 spell slots to do one thing.” Somebody asked r/dndnext in 2024 what if these spells worked on a hit like a smite, and one reply called it, “I would be willing to bet that this is going to be the case in the 2024 PHB.” He was right. (u/Radidactyl, r/dndnext ; u/Jokerlaughll and u/ElizaAlex_01, r/dndnext, r/dndnext)

    Shoot clusters, keep a dart handy, stop upcasting it, and check where your barbarian is standing before you pull the trigger. What’s the most enemies you’ve ever caught in one of these, and be honest, how many of them were your own party? And for the 2024 rangers, has losing the concentration finally put this on your prepared list? Let me know in the comments below, and until next time, roll high and stay ridiculous.

    Post Views: 25
    cheese hail of thorns Ranger
    Share. Facebook Twitter Pinterest LinkedIn Tumblr Email
    Previous ArticleHail of Thorns Spell in D&D 5e, One Arrow, Shotgun Rules
    dumbestdnd
    • Website

    Related Posts

    Level 1

    Hail of Thorns Spell in D&D 5e, One Arrow, Shotgun Rules

    November 14, 2026
    Level 1

    Guiding Bolt Spell in D&D: Uses, Cheeses, and Cursed Ideas

    November 13, 2026
    Level 1

    Guiding Bolt Spell in D&D 5e, 4d6 and a Free Sneak Attack

    November 12, 2026
    Add A Comment

    Comments are closed.

    Available Now!
    Get the PDFInstant download — play tonight Grab the PaperbackShips from Amazon
    Latest Encounters

    Get Lucky with Lute Boxes

    Calvin and the Drip Monks

    1 2 3 … 90 Next
    About Dumbest DnD

    We're Trent and John, the main writers here at Dumbest DnD. We started this site as a way for busy DMs to drop ridiculous encounters into their sessions with minimal prep. We hope you find something you like!

    Instagram YouTube Reddit
    Latest Resources

    Hail of Thorns Spell in D&D: Uses, Cheeses, and Shooting Your Own Barbarian

    Hail of Thorns Spell in D&D 5e, One Arrow, Shotgun Rules

    1 2 3 … 56 Next
    Instagram YouTube
    • Privacy Policy
    • Subscribe
    © 2026 Dumbest DnD

    Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.